Search results

Re: \"The Gathering\" Question I'm sorry Springer, but you are confusing *my* arguments too. the 'playing cards close to chest = lying = what I don't think JMS would do' line of reasoning related not to G'Kar's line, your points are perfectly logical there; I wouldn't argue the G'Kar at the...

Whoops, my mistake. Guess I didn't look hard enough to see if it had come up before. Should I delete this thread, or just leave it because it now has a link back to the original thread?

Has anyone seen the new Space: Above and Beyond DVD set? Great series, but someone's going to find themselves in deep spoo over the menu screens: ! :eek: :lol:

Re: \"The Gathering\" Question Sorry, but the 'keeping cards close to chest' argument holds no water with me. If he was doing that, why bother to lie about the Minbari at all? Why not simply not point out ANY race as being the oldest? The way you phrase it seems to imply that he had to either...

Re: \"The Gathering\" Question Always old, no doubt, but as the balance of evidence appears to show, not the oldest.

Re: \"The Gathering\" Question I think a few words from the man himself can settle this debate: "The Minbari are the oldest of the different alien civilizations, and largely kept to themselves." Thats from one of his Genie posts, made on Wed Jan 01, 1992. Read it here...