B5TV.COM (http://www.b5tv.com/index.php)
-   B5.world (http://www.b5tv.com/forumdisplay.php?f=17)
-   -   Cenuri and narms (http://www.b5tv.com/showthread.php?t=29200)

ajac May 14th 12 17:36

Cenuri and narms
I LOVE THIS SERIES but it just hit me on my like 100th rematch of hte series... are the narm suppose to be Africans/slave races of Earth and the Centuri suppose to be the rich man taking there land? it just seems so.

JoeD80 May 14th 12 19:23

Re: Cenuri and narms
It's more of a general sense of history. These themes manifest in different places and times. I've seen Joe describe the Centauri concept as Roman, Japanese, and British, and I'm sure there are many other interpretations out there.

Jade Jaguar May 16th 12 08:12

Re: Cenuri and narms
The Centauri seemed rather Roman to me, or perhaps Italians from late dark ages to the early Renaissance.

The Narns seemed sort of Japanese, (as with the samurai of my avatar,) but also kind of African, especially in decor. And, the Japanese as a whole hadn't been subjugated, as had the Narns.

I think JMS drew on many sources for his depictions, and we aren't really meant to take the B5 races as close analogs for any human races, or cultures. But, there are often obvious parallels.

Alioth May 16th 12 10:10

Re: Cenuri and narms
It's definitely a good thing, IMHO, that JMS didn't make the alien races clearly analogous to any particular human culture or civilization, avoided obvious or direct historical analogs, and in general avoided making episodes synching with current political or social events and whatnot (for the most part I get that impression, although I didn't view the show at the time it aired in the 90s so I'm not sure if there may have been one or two eps like that, but various ST franchise shows were--sometimes annoyingly--riddled with these). There are strands of it that resonate or "rhyme" with our history, but other strands in the same depicted character or culture or event that make it in other ways very different from that same history we wish to try comparing to. In other words, we're forced to see it for what it is itself, and not always judge with the benefit of hindsight from our own history.

And history itself never completely "repeats", but it can rhyme--and we need to be on our toes to notice the significant differences in the new, as well as the similarities, in order to deal with the new situations favorably.

RW7427 May 26th 12 02:57

Re: Cenuri and narms
I always thought of the Centauri like the French of Napolean's time.

Kara Baxter May 26th 12 07:22

Re: Cenuri and narms
There's a theme??

I just notice the weird clothes.

All times are GMT. The time now is 18:20.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
2001 - 2018 B5TV.COM